Some negative reviews for pronouns in a game

Nope.

I wear pants more than I wear a skirt or dress but that that doesn’t make me male. My girlfriend who I call wife sometimes, calls me hubby every now again, that doesn’t make me male. I’m quite muscular and very hairy*, that doesn’t make me male.

But someone else in the same circumstance may call themselves male because that is how gender works.

Not all transgender people transition, there is no threshold for when you are allowed to change whether you can call yourself male or female

It really is as simple as sex=/=gender. The two correlate for almost everyone but the terms do in fact have different meanings and are not interchangeable.

*my Dad says I’m just built like the men on his side of the family, oh well

6 Likes

Gender = Gender. Which is defined by your chromosomes. Genitalia has nothing to do with it.

?

3 Likes

Your sex is determined by your chromosomes, if you have a Y you are male, if you don’t have a Y you are female. Sex in this regard means the chromosomes not genitalia.

XXY people are male in regards to their sex but can be any gender they identify with just like any other person XX, XY, XXX whatever.

A transgender MtF is female by gender but is still a male by sex (that is a hugely inflamatory statement I know but I say it in hopes that it helps someone understand the difference, it is not mean to offend)

Maybe some day people will be able to change their chromosomes but I’m pretty sure the zombie apocalypse will come first.

7 Likes

Sounds like gender identity, not gender.

2 Likes

I haven’t read the whole thing so sorry If I repeat something. :see_no_evil:

What you are refering to there is the biological sex, sex characteristics, and as @nebula7 says there’s more to just XX and XY (XXY, X0…) and genitalia is varied.

Gender identity is how you feel, you could feel male or female, some people don’t feel like one or the other but rather female and male at the same time, partially male or female or don’t identify with any of the two. (There’s terms for every type and ofc more)

Then there’s sexual orientation we’re more familiar with it but yeah It’s same thing in that it’s more like a gradient, is what you like: Females, males, the two, with different intensity, you don’t care about the gender or don’t feel attracion for any gender… and this changes trough your life.

Finally gender expresion that’s the blue for boys, pink for girls, games for boys, dolls for girls. How femenine or masculine are you base on the social norms/perceptions, this is where androgynous comes from.

And that’s basically Sexual Diversity, so any combination you can think of regarding every point is not just valid and wonderful but also real. There’s not two people alike ^^

So you should refer to people as they want to be identify as, same with how you want to be called in a particular way, example: Transgender woman

7 Likes

Here is an article about the whole issue (saves some time reading it all) :slight_smile:

I didnt interfere anymore in this discussion because I dont like to be called dishonest, luckily this person who wrote this article saw the same thing.

6 Likes

Big thanks @Fraggles for raising the bar in this discussion.

Now if I may. changes title of discussion

4 Likes

aaand @nebula7 changed it back. Makes this feature a whole bunch less useful.

Man the current title doesn’t tell ppl ANYTHING about the thread.

I can do the same mate

Are you for real?
help me @delenn13

3 Likes

Thanks! I want to read trough all of It tho ^^

The genderbread thing was really cool @YQMaoski didn’t know about that hahaha much more visual than just saying things, sorry for repeating stuff everybody > <

7 Likes

Just curious can you edit someone elses title? Or did I misunderstand it?

6 Likes

yup yup, once yr a regular user i think

2 Likes

Yeah exactly this and nebula is enjoying changing it back

3 Likes

it’s her thread man; she’s definitely entitled to it (edit: lol it actually isn’t but maybe this is what yoshi wants? it was yoshi’s choice to begin with)

so y i believe @yoshirules should be the one deciding on that issue

5 Likes

I didnt know that thanks
But now I am even more curious to what did you change it both? @anon74641759 and @nebula7 :slightly_smiling_face:

4 Likes

You can see on the edits to the main post the changes.

We can only change the titles and tags, not the text within the body of the post

4 Likes

yeah it’s not nebula’s and the current title doesn’t reflect the content, it’s simply clickbait atm

2 Likes

Thanks but I dont see it only got 4 messages about editing but it doesnt show what changed

2 Likes

When you click on the orange pencil with the 4 next to it, it will show what was changed and who did it when.

5 Likes

Haha great thank you! Wouldnt have found it without help :blush:

3 Likes

I made a character in battletech yesterday i don’t see what the big deal is. If you pick they you just get access to all available male/female pilot portraits there’s no voice option in the creation section. People are just grossly overreacting like i told @onLooSe yesterday.

4 Likes