I think what makes a bad or good game is really based on if you as an individual find the game resonates with you…
Like I said in:
https://206.81.1.216/t/favorite-movie/14977/14
I think most video games are ‘fun’ to play, the big question is what games do you play and want/can’t wait to get back to it. Not simply an addictive game but something with staying power or deeper meaning.
There are characters, moments and experiences we all remember from games, I would argue those tend to be the ‘good games’.