While you praise Infinite ( and it’s not generally viewed as super game ) you point at Last of us as great game ( and it’s generally viewed as super good ) i personally found it boring 
SO you see there i’m going. Opinions. Different preferences and such.
God of War on the other hand i found to be excellent. Both story and game are just amazing on every aspect.
Uncharted (again viewed as one of Playstaton flagships ) ? One of the most boring game series i’ve had displeasure of playing.
And in the end RDR2 ? It’s good. But it’s good on a level which has more of a mechanical , objective side . It;s technically impressive,has top notch writing and tons of content and work put into it but it lacks that ‘gamy’ aspect. It’s more of a super car made for results than a car which has a ‘soul’ .
So you know. Tastes i guess?
I think that modern art is shit in general,but it sells for millions and artists are viewed as some sort of masterminds. Same goes with games i guess.
I’ll be honest i have no clue what is the purpose of this thread. I just saw names of games i know and have played. 
P.S ANother example. I’m playing through Spiderman 2018 ( PS4 exclusive ) and it’s supposed to be this amazing game and blah blah and it’sjust an OKAY game. Not a waste of money or time but nothing of what i was expecting .